LETSBuzz Book Club 27th August 2000

A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius by Dave Eggers

Even before this book starts, there is an unusual and amazing amount of stuff to read - the verso credits page (sic Andrew) contains a lots of personal facts and personal opinions, which is not normal. There's more, including a breakdown of production costs and a "Rules and Suggestions for this book" section which tells you which bits of the book are boring and which bits can be ignored.

The story, when it eventually begins, is sort-of-autobiographical and the first third is truly heartbreaking, being the story of the author's parents both dying, very close together, and his bringing up - in his 20s - his seven year old brother "Tofe" (for Christopher). This was well written and very interesting.

Unfortunately, the story moves to California where they produce a magazine, and this part truly is boring (as the author himself admits in his "rules and suggestions"). The story becomes less about the interesting Tofe, which is a shame.

Doreen didn't particularly like the book, which was a "pretty smart-arse book" written in a very knowing way.

Jean had also read this book, and like Doreen she had bought it on the strength of reading excerpts. Unlike Doreen, however, Jean did not read the non-story bits at the beginning until she finished the book - and maybe this made her feel less negative about it. She agreed that the magazine story was very dull, and so was the account of the author's attempt to get onto a TV show.

The book read very true-to-life - the story of the 20 year olds' reminded her of intelligent people of this age she'd known some years ago and felt very accurate. True, they could also be irritating but she enjoyed this aspect of the book.

The first part of the book was very moving, as was the story of the author's effective single-parenthood. Jean recommends this sometimes very funny book.
Doreen

White Teeth by Zadie Smith

This first novel was a jolly good read. It's a two-family saga, one Bengali and one white man married to a Jamaican girl, starting just after the second world war.

The book deals with growing up in this country being black, Asian or mixed race. It's a story about being an outsider, and also about social life in London.

The book is extremely funny and very well done, and Doreen really enjoyed it. A thorough recommendation.
Doreen

Ghostwritten by David Mitchell

Another first book, this time a collection of connected stories. It's very clever, the author uses a different style for each story (for example romance, or thriller, or ghost story). One needs to read it with attention, because characters from one story pop up in others. A very interesting and enjoyable book.
Doreen

Girl with a Pearl Earring by Tracy Chevalier

A novel built around Vermeer's picture of same. The made-up story is about the pictured girl going to work in Vermeer's unhappy household. The girl's father was a Delft tile painter, and the girl herself is really an artist - in her spare time she helps Vermeer in his studio, making up paints and so forth; she doesn't watch him painting, but she sees the pictures taking shape. (To read this book you need another book, of Vermeer's paintings, to hand).

A fairly light book, but very nicely done with a strong sense of place and very detailed.
Doreen

For the Relief of Unbearable Urges by Nathan Englander

A book of short stories by the (apparently, going by his picture) young author, who writes with the understanding and knowledge of the world of a 60-year old. The stories, all very powerful, are mostly about orthodox Jews; they have an undercurrent of sadness, and real humour. Really well written and highly recommended.
Jean

In the Skin of a Lion by Michael Ondaatje

Reminiscent of The English Patient, and written before it, some of the characters in this book reappear in that novel - for example, there's a burglar called Carravagio and a child called Hannah.

A heart-rending romance, or rather pair of romances, run through the book, which is about immigrants in America. The book pulls together lots of disparate stories, and you see connections falling into place.

The stories are fascinating and very well written - Jean liked the book more than The English Patient. Very good and powerfully romantic.
Jean

Westward Ho! by Charles Kingsley

Gill read this boom whilst she was "doing Devon". The book was written in 1855 and set in the Elizabethan era, when Devon was a significant departure point for the New World. At first she was put off by the extreme anti-Catholicism and anti-Spanish tone of the book - which is not at all PC - but later she recognized that this was actually how the Elizabethans looked, seen through the Victorian eyes of a clergyman's son. The women, too, were all stereotypical.

Westward Ho! is a boys' adventure book which Gill really enjoyed - she's not sure why. But the story was never predictable.
Gill

The Houdini Girl by Martyn Bedford

This is the author's third novel, and Andrew felt that the novelist is "destined to disappoint me slightly more with each new novel."

The book is about Red, a magician who is bewitched into a romance with Rosa, an Irishwoman. She then disappears and the book follows Red's attempt to find out what has happened. Unfortunately, virtually all the characters in the book are unpleasant, and half-way through Andrew really didn't care anymore. He felt the trip to Amsterdam was included in order to add a bit of salaciousness into the story (shades of John Irving, chorused the bookclub).
Andrew

For Esme - with Love and Squalor by J D Salinger

"Written nearly 50 years ago but not at all dated." Salinger has written very few books and is a recluse - and having recently read this collection Andrew feels that it's a tragedy that Salinger hasn't written more, given the strength of his writing and what he has to say about the human condtition. The stories are beautifully written, exquisite - whatever it is that makes a good short story, Salinger had it. "The title story nearly made me cry, and I had to bite my tongue on the train to stop it making me laught out loud."
Andrew

The Country Ahead of us the Country Behind by David Guterson

Guterson clearly hadn't a clue what makes a good short story (unlike Salinger). The stories in this book, not recommended, just don't work. They are all set in familiar Guterson territory, and feature lots of Iron-John stuff, manly pursuits and hunting. Don't read it.
Andrew

Man and Boy by Tony Parsons

Caroline had put off reading this book for a long time, but when she got around to it she liked it, especially the relationship between father and son. There was a really sad bit where the father had to explain to the child that he was still loved by his mother ("Huh," said Doreen, "that's a straight lift from Kramer v Kramer"). Some of the story, however, was hard to credit - the narrator finds a girlfriend, whose daughter just happens to strike up a friendship with his son; and the story of his dying father is also difficult to believe, as is the final airport dash.

But Caroline enjoyed it, as did Jean.
Caroline

The Looking Glass by Michèle Roberts

Roberts' latest novel, marking her return to form. Set in France, as are many of her books, in the early twentieth century the book follows the story of various women who end up in the household of a male poet. Caroline really enjoyed the book, including "a lot of mermaid imagery" and recommends it.
Caroline

The Journals of Sylvia Plath

This book was not what Caroline had expected, being the collection virtually every piece of paper known to have been written on by Plath. It's more an academic source than a readable book, so Caroline has just skimmed through it "looking for the good bits."
Caroline

No Man's Land by George Monbiot

The book of Monbiot's journey through East Africa, visiting the disappearing people - the nomadic tribes. It's a sad book - everywhere the nomads and/or their way of life is under attack, they are seen as undesirables, with no proper loyalty to a state and making no economic contribution. The nomads are being rendered "homeless" by game parks, governments and capitalism, they are being forced to "settle" and participate (in poverty, of course) in the cash economy. There was an interesting section where Monbiot interviews Richard Leakey, who puts a strong case against monbiot's thesis, almost convincing the author until he realises that Leakey's view is really a rather old-fashioned (but well-meaning) one.

A book that everybody should read.

Coincidentally, Seán had recently read about the destruction of the cattle of Africa by the rinderpest virus, brought in the nineteenth century. This had the effect of killing virtually all of the nomad's cattle and reducing them to starvation an destitution, in which condition they were easily subdued by the colonizers. These same colonizers found a largely uninhabited wilderness, a situation which they tried to recreate in the great game parks, without realising that this was an irregular condition brought about by a cattle plague: as a result, the African people who lived in harmony with nature have been excluded.
Caroline

Interpreter of Maladies by Jhumpa Lahiri

A not very inspiring collection of stories about Indian people, set in India and the United States, which didn't move Seán very much. The book was so forgettable that a month after finishing it he picked it up to start reading it, convinced (until he started) that he hadn't yet read it.
Seán

The Code Book by Simon Singh

Another book by the author of Fermat's Last Theorem, this should satisfy numerate lovers of puzzles, language and logic. No mathematical ability is needed to follow the book, just the ability to follow an argument.

The book opens strongly at the trial of Mary Queen of Scots, where her life is forfeit should her enciphered correspondence be read. This provides an opening for Singh to relate a history of the techniques used in attempts to make correspondence secret, and to read the secrets: since ancient times men - mostly men, mostly in pursuit of war - have used the latest techniques both to make and break ciphers and codes.

During the course of the book Singh relates the story of new cipher techniques and how in turn each method was cracked, in an arms race which - as he relates it - is almost over. Digressions include the Rosetta stone, Egypian hieroglyphics and the decipherment of Linear A - all fascinating stuff. Finally, by the middle of the twentieth century formidable technologies made secret messages almost impenetrable - technologies including, of course, Enigma.

The book deals with Enigma at length, and shows how it was broken by a combination of insight, genius and German fallibility. Had the Germans used it properly, it probably would not have yielded to Bletchley Park's efforts.

Rather frustratingly at this point, Singh mentions the American and British wartime cipher machines but gives no further details - and this raises the question of secrecy, because the more contemporary his account becomes the less information is available. The vast majority of work in these areas is carried out by governments, and they are understandably wary of sharing their discoveries.

As an example, the unbreakable-by-any-publicly-known-means technology of RSA encryption, available freely to many millions of computer users the world over, was discovered three years earlier by researchers at GCHQ.

Finally, Singh deals with quantum computers - if buildable, they might easily crack all current encryption systems - but they will also offer the potential of a new, never crackable system. The arms race would be over, and for the first time secure messages would remain secure, for ever.
Seán

The Poisonwood Bible by Barbara Kingsolver

A terrific book, compulsive reading. The book is narrated by three daughters and their mother, and the characterisation of each person in their writing is masterful. There was never any need to even think who's voice one was reading - one just knew.

The book tells of an American missionary and his family, who go to live and work in the Congo just before independence, and it follows through to their departure and beyond. Their experiences in Africa shape all of their lives.

The story is detailed and involving, the writing always good and sometimes very moving and passionate. Seán wanted to cry when he read the very brief, matter-of-fact death of one child, and felt moved to anger by the Belgian and American governments' treatment of the people of the Congo.

A highly recommended book.


The frames have gone all funny - click to make it good.